Why Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg went to war over WordPress

Today, I’m talking with Matt Mullenweg, the laminitis and CEO of Automattic, the genitor institution of WordPress.com, Tumblr, and a full big of different products similar the caller cross-platform messaging work Beeper. 

This is Matt’s 3rd clip connected Decoder; backmost successful 2022, we had him connected twice, archetypal to talk astir Automattic and WordPress broadly and past to speech astir Tumblr and the aboriginal of societal networking. He’s backmost present due to the fact that Automattic conscionable turned 20, and I truly wanted to speech astir however the adjacent 20 years of moving 1 of the astir ascendant platforms connected the web mightiness look arsenic changes to hunt and AI endanger to alteration everything else, and assorted lawsuits endanger to alteration the quality of WordPress itself.

Make nary mistake, WordPress is 1 of the astir ascendant platforms connected the web, if not the most dominant. Something similar 43 percent of websites tally connected WordPress, successful 1 of its galore flavors. That includes The Verge — the backend of our website is hosted by WordPress VIP. So this mightiness beryllium the archetypal reverse disclosure connected the show. Technically, we’re Matt’s customer, and similar immoderate bully customer, I made diagnostic requests. 

A large crushed for that is WordPress is open-source, and similar truthful galore open-source projects, WordPress has a precise analyzable structure. There’s the nonprofit WordPress Foundation that owns the WordPress trademark. There’s WordPress.org, from which the open-source task is managed by Matt himself. Then there’s Automattic, which is the for-profit institution that offers its ain tract hosting and endeavor services connected apical of the halfway WordPress technology, and which contributes an tremendous magnitude of codification backmost to the open-source WordPress project.

Understanding that operation is truly important due to the fact that determination has been a batch of play successful the satellite of WordPress recently. Last year, Matt essentially went to war, publically and successful the courts, against a hosting institution called WP Engine that competes with Automattic. Matt felt WP Engine wasn’t operating successful the tone of open-source by contributing precise small backmost to the WordPress codification base.

So Matt filed a suit against the institution portion revoking its entree to halfway WordPress technologies. Many radical felt this was incredibly retired of bounds for Matt and a usurpation of his presumption arsenic a cardinal steward of the WordPress project, and determination has been important fallout astatine Automattic and the broader WordPress community.  

It’s been a long, drawn-out saga. WP Engine countersued, and Automattic was forced to reverse immoderate of its retaliatory efforts against the company. But the lawsuits are ongoing, and they’re acold from resolved. That said, Matt was consenting to travel connected the amusement and speech done immoderate of this reasoning here, wherefore helium made immoderate of the decisions helium did, and besides what helium regrets astir however immoderate of this went down. 

Matt and I talked astir the aboriginal of the web, too, and however he’s reasoning astir the changes we’re seeing to hunt and website sustainability arsenic the generative AI roar continues to upend however radical usage the internet. Matt is notably a batch much optimistic astir this than galore of the website owners we perceive from regularly present astatine The Verge, and he’s not convinced AI is going to wreck the web. 

We besides talked astir Beeper, the cross-platform messaging work that Automattic acquired past year. Beeper got into immoderate blistery h2o with Apple erstwhile it tried and yet failed to bring iMessage to Android. But Matt is truly excited astir Beeper’s halfway product. Automattic has acquired a mates different startups and efficaciously combined them each to effort and supercharge Beeper’s maturation successful the coming months and years.

There’s a batch successful this conversation, and Matt is arsenic candid and sincere arsenic ever. I deliberation you’re going to similar it. 

Okay: Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg. Here we go.

This interrogation has been lightly edited for magnitude and clarity. 

Matt Mullenweg, you’re the co-founder and CEO of Automattic, the genitor institution of WordPress, and galore different things. Welcome backmost to Decoder.

Thank you truthful much. The satellite has changed. So overmuch has been going connected since I was past on. It’s large to drawback up.

I consciousness similar we had you connected twice successful one year, and that was 3 years ago, past galore things happened, and I’ve been dying to speech to you astir updates to the worldly we talked astir the past clip you were on. And past a clump of caller things, including immoderate precise melodramatic caller things, person occurred since past time.

We person immoderate chill acquisitions and launches coming up. So yeah, a batch to cover.

Let’s commencement there. People are evidently acquainted with WordPress. I ideate radical are acquainted with Tumblr, which is different happening that you were technically the CEO of, I believe. But since then, you’ve acquired different companies. You’ve acquired companies similar Beeper and immoderate others. What bash you deliberation of arsenic Automattic today? What’s the thesis of the company?

I cognize you emotion talking astir org charts and organizational structures, truthful it’s interesting. The WordPress broadside of the concern we telephone “Ecosystem,” right? It’s similar gardening. There’s a immense fig of players, and that’s truly benignant of what we’re champion known for. I’ve been doing WordPress present for 22 years. I started erstwhile I was 19, and that’s WordPress.com, it’s WordPress VIP, which we’re precise arrogant to person Vox arsenic a customer.

Oh, wait, I request to disclose this. This is the first-ever reverse disclosure, I think, connected The Verge oregon Decoder. Usually, I disclose erstwhile there’s a concern relationship, but successful this case, we are your client. 

[Laughs] Yep, truthful convey you. We’re honored. 

The Verge runs connected WordPress, truthful the struggle is the different way. You’ve got to support maine arsenic a customer.

Well, I’ll bash my champion connected this. And no, that’s really the thrill of it too, is seeing publications you travel and things similar that usage the software, it’s precise rewarding. Now, the different broadside of Automattic we telephone Cosmos, and that’s the apps, and that’s been a precise breathtaking spot to enactment successful the past fewer years.

Now, you mentioned Beeper, which is really doing its large nationalist motorboat this July successful New York, truthful I anticipation to get you there. We did 2 acquisitions, Texts and Beeper. We combined them, and we’re precise excited. I was really conscionable with that squad a small spot earlier today. The different 1 [we added] just past week was Clay. So, if you aren’t familiar, Clay is simply a idiosyncratic CRM. One of the apical requests we heard from Beeper users is like, “Okay, I’ve got each my messaging apps…”

Actually, I should astir apt accidental what Beeper is. You person astir apt much than 1 messaging level you usage regularly, right?

Yeah.

So the chill happening astir Beeper is that it tin bring them each successful one. WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, each of that. The different chill happening it does is that it tin usage aggregate accounts of those. So you tin person aggregate Signal accounts and aggregate WhatsApp accounts, each successful 1 device, and you tin connection it connected your desktop, mobile, everything, and it does it each securely. That’s the caller stuff. We figured retired however to marque this each tally locally connected your device, and truthful it’s conscionable arsenic unafraid arsenic utilizing 1 of these autochthonal apps.

But what we heard is radical say, “Well, present I’ve got excessively overmuch worldly going on. Who’s important? What should I do?” That’s wherever Clay’s CRM comes in. CRM stands for lawsuit narration management, truthful usually apps similar Salesforce. But this is simply a idiosyncratic 1 that’s beauteous slick.

When you accidental “personal CRM,” what’s absorbing is that the throughline for a batch of what you are doing is that tiny businesses, businesses of each kinds, usage WordPress. They’re connected the web, and a batch of what the web is utilized for lately is simply a tiny concern storefront, oregon a concern storefront, oregon immoderate commercialized enterprise. Things similar a CRM, a substance messaging platform, each of that worldly — it connects precise profoundly to conscionable e-commerce successful general.

But you’re talking astir a idiosyncratic CRM. What’s the divided for you betwixt WordPress arsenic an endeavor e-commerce institution and WordPress arsenic a purveyor of user products?

I accidental we’re precise fortunate to beryllium portion of the procreation that was… they called it “the consumerization of IT.” It was led by folks similar Slack who came successful and said, “Hey, we’re conscionable going to marque a large idiosyncratic acquisition and it’s going to beryllium quirky, it’s going to beryllium fun, it’s not going to beryllium boring, it’s going to beryllium colorful and we’re going to physique the concern features. So it scales and it does that benignant of stuff, but we’re going to commencement from that large idiosyncratic experience.”

There’s immoderate endeavor bundle historically that didn’t commencement there. If you’re connected an aged SAP instal oregon thing similar that, nary one’s waking up being like, “Yeah, I got to get successful there.”

Slack, notably present owned by Salesforce, which is fascinating. That’s the 2 sides of that equation coming together.

Well, I deliberation these companies, including Salesforce, person been doing a batch to reinvest successful their interfaces and everything else. So with Clay — and the URL’s clay.earth; unfortunately, there’s different large institution called Clay that does much endeavor worldly — truthful if you spell to clay.earth, it’ll beryllium the idiosyncratic one. 

So what makes it idiosyncratic versus enterprise? We commencement from things connected your computer, similar your code book. We hook successful societal networks, truthful you tin enactment successful each your societal networks. We’ll benignant of de-dupe it. We stress things similar birthdays. It brings successful your calendar, iMessage, and WhatsApp messages close now. That’s benignant of what Clay was doing before, and what we’re going to beryllium gathering present is that it’ll conscionable plug into Beeper, and past immoderate you person plugged into Beeper, nevertheless galore networks, immoderate you’re doing there, it’ll bring each those messages in. 

Then it tin commencement to, for example, bash amusive worldly similar sorting your contacts by however adjacent your narration is, which tin bash clever things. Like, not conscionable look astatine however often you interaction them, but who’s sending much messages, which way, and is it weekdays oregon weekends? There’s a batch you tin benignant of infer erstwhile you person communication, and we’re precise excited to spot wherever that goes.

I would recognize if you were saying this was an endeavor product. I would wholly recognize wherefore you’ve invested successful Beeper and Texts, and wherefore you’ve invested successful thing similar Clay, right? You’re starting a website, you’re going to bash immoderate e-commerce, you request an outbound messaging platform, and you request a lawsuit narration absorption tool. You privation to cognize who your champion customers are. This is each conscionable value-adds to the commerce platform.

What’s the gross exemplary for these arsenic user products? Are you going to complaint for them?

Yeah, truthful we’ll decidedly cross-promote this stuff. But what you conscionable said — who are your champion customers, that benignant of reporting — that’s conscionable each built into WooCommerce and WordPress, truthful you don’t request to spell betwixt apps.

As for the gross models we’re imagining… Clay already has a Clay for Teams, truthful your full squad tin stock contacts, stock updates, and you tin usage it successful a team-like fashion. And they’ve got a pricing exemplary there, and they were making revenue. So it was bully to get a institution that already had a gross model.

With Beeper, we’re inactive figuring it out. But what I fishy is there’ll beryllium 2 things. It’ll beryllium escaped up to a definite fig of accounts, and if you’re a ace powerfulness idiosyncratic and you privation to link more, determination could beryllium a monthly charge. And past the different happening is that determination mightiness beryllium definite connections that are ever paid. So let’s accidental you privation to link to a Bloomberg terminal chat, we’re astir apt going to complaint you for that due to the fact that you’re much of a concern user.

Also, a batch of the messaging platforms enactment concern features now, similar WhatsApp for business. There’s adjacent iMessage for business. I don’t cognize if you’ve ever seen this? 

Yeah.

But famously, iMessage, which antecedently was like, “No APIs, we’re going to crush Beeper,” successful a erstwhile iteration, present has a full integration strategy for it. So arsenic we enactment much and much of these bridges to antithetic networks, I deliberation determination are a batch of opportunities there.

Is the Beeper architecture inactive moving an lawsuit of spectator messaging apps successful the unreality connected your behalf and relaying them to you, oregon are you much integrated now?

There are inactive 2 unreality bridges, but portion of what we’re relaunching is that we’ve re-architected the full happening with the Texts technology, truthful it each goes section now.

So iMessage is coming locally to your telephone done Beeper?

iMessage is the 1 that we bash not enactment connected mobile. It is supported connected desktop, conscionable similar TextIt, successful this benignant of mode that Apple said oregon indicated it was good with. But yeah, we’re not going to fight that combat again. We’re way, way, mode distant from it. Not touching that with a 100-foot pole.

Is the extremity present that these apps should beryllium revenue-generating user products? Or are they bully additions to the endeavor stack that besides mightiness person user elements?

I’m reasoning of it 100 percent arsenic creating thing consumer-first, actually, that past has paths if you’re a powerfulness idiosyncratic to bash much team-like collaborative oregon business-like things connected it. But archetypal and foremost, I privation to get Beeper to 100 cardinal users. I consciousness that’s really benignant of the archetypal merchandise from Automattic that has the imaginable to really beryllium really, truly ample due to the fact that its usage is benignant of a superset of each messaging network, and the powerfulness users are the astir predominant users connected each of those.

Right now, it’s comparatively small. No 1 feels that threatened. If you get to 100 cardinal users and the superior interface for WhatsApp, Signal, and iMessage is really Beeper, those apps volition consciousness threatened. There’s thing keeping those companies from saying, “You’ve taken our lawsuit away, we’re shutting you down.” Have you had those conversations yet?

Well, I deliberation the quality is that we’re not trying to instrumentality the lawsuit away. We’re trying to springiness them an interface wherever they tin usage the web adjacent more, link with much people, and usage the concern features. If they person immoderate mode to monetize, we’re conscionable going to nexus to it. We’re not trying to debar that. So we privation to enactment each of these networks, which by the way, we’re investing immense amounts to tally everything, truthful we’re trying to beryllium complementary.

Because they privation to beryllium the app connected your telephone done which you bash many, galore different things. If the app connected the telephone is Beeper…

The exemplary that we spot radical usage Beeper is that they don’t get escaped of the autochthonal app. They support it. Because it’s ever going to beryllium thing there, similar a functionality oregon something, that you’re going to privation the app for. And Beeper is much for managing tons of messages, getting the section LLMs, giving you quality crossed networks, things that are powerfulness idiosyncratic features. But I deliberation determination are a batch of powerfulness users.

So, a unusual happening that is happening with Beeper present is that France is the fig 1 country, and it started to spell viral successful definite ways, and immoderate of that is radical wanting to beryllium capable to cheque their messages without getting excessively distracted. They telephone it “Friends without Feeds,” but they inactive spell backmost to the feeds, don’t worry. They’re doing conscionable fine. It’s conscionable sometimes, if you’re successful a gathering oregon something, you conscionable privation to instrumentality a speedy look, that benignant of distraction-free mode is truly nice.

That’s truly interesting. One of the reasons that I’m pushing connected this is that arsenic we’re speaking, I deliberation you’re days distant from Automattic turning 20 years aged arsenic a company. Automattic, WordPress, and these different apps are each portion of the cloth of the web. Broadly speaking, astir 43 percent of the web runs connected WordPress.

Some of these fights that Beepers has had successful the past are similar however bash we physique unfastened architectures retired of services that are fundamentally closed, usage web technologies to walk that worldly to people, and what benignant of fights volition we person there. There’s the unfastened root combat and WordPress that I privation to speech astir successful depth.

But it feels similar present astatine 20 years old, the web is changing successful meaningful ways. And the web arsenic an endeavor level mightiness beryllium headed toward ever higher heights, and arsenic a user media level mightiness beryllium headed toward ever little lows. I’m wondering, arsenic you deliberation astir these investments, these tools, and the apps versus the ecosystem, whether you consciousness that hostility playing out?

No. So I’m really going to inquire you to grow a small connected what you spot arsenic these little lows, due to the fact that it feels similar arsenic we get much compute astatine the edge, arsenic the devices go much powerful, broadband becomes ever much ubiquitous — you can’t flight it anyplace present with Starlink — that there’s a spot of a benignant of swinging backmost towards these apps and user-centric things. Even the regulatory situation is precise friendly.

And that’s what I would propulsion it apart. As an exertion platform, the web is, I think, astatine its highest and possibly with higher highs to come. Web apps are the astir absorbing they’ve ever been. Every almighty AI exertion is mostly expressed arsenic a web app, particularly connected desktop. Google is virtually demonstrating Veo 3 arsenic a web app. Google CEO Sundar Pichai is like, “I’m drafting radical to the desktop web to usage these applications successful Chrome connected the web.”

Figma exists, right? It’s 1 of the astir almighty plan tools, and it’s a web app. As an exertion platform, the web is astatine its highest it’s ever been. Some of the regulatory changes, the Fortnite lawsuit, arsenic a transaction platform, the web is going to deed higher highs due to the fact that we’re going to spot much transactions pushed to the web. That’s thing other I privation to speech to you about.

I’m saying, arsenic a media platform, arsenic a papers viewer, the question I’ve been asking each CEO is, “Why would I commencement a website today?” I would commencement a TikTok channel. I would commencement a YouTube channel. That’s however you scope consumers with media. The web arsenic a media level seems to beryllium astatine its astir perilous moment, and that’s truly the divided I’m talking about. Applications, transactions, and the web are precise intelligibly astatine a highest with perchance higher highs to come. As a media platform, media companies are going retired of concern connected the web fundamentally each day.

There’s a batch successful there, right? Because you benignant of deed the creator thing. We deed societal networks. I’ll commencement with your question: why, if I’m fashionable connected TikTok, would I commencement a website? Well, one, truthful you’re not a one-hit wonder, and I deliberation we’ve seen adjacent immoderate of the biggest creators connected a definite level volition often person occupation getting arsenic fashionable connected different one.

So you request to make a nonstop narration with your assemblage due to the fact that arsenic agelong arsenic your assemblage is afloat mediated by this happening you don’t power — YouTube, TikTok, Reels, immoderate it is — you’ll person a run. But these things alteration generationally sometimes. People determination from 1 to the other. The concern models change, and what they stress changes. If you’re a creator who was conscionable all-in connected Facebook 10 years agone due to the fact that you thought thing would ever regenerate Facebook, you mightiness beryllium facing immoderate of the aforesaid things that these media companies are facing that haven’t adapted and truly embraced their users.

I deliberation that the media happening is besides benignant of analyzable due to the fact that we had a existent degradation of the idiosyncratic acquisition and benignant of the velocity of sites, the mode advertizing would work, and dilatory down your browser, and everything. Present institution excluded, but for immoderate different media sites, you’d load them, and it’s astir similar they’re having trouble. It’s hard to work the nonfiction due to the fact that it keeps moving astir arsenic the ads load, and truthful I felt similar that was a decease spiral for immoderate of these sites that might’ve over-monetized.

I’m going to spell each the mode present to the section stuff-

Actually, tin I conscionable propulsion connected over-monetized for 1 second?

Yeah.

Over-monetized. You tin work that successful respective ways. I deliberation what you mean is they enactment excessively overmuch crap connected the leafage and past the idiosyncratic acquisition was degraded, and cipher ever wants to spell to a section quality tract again.

The different mode to work it is that they had nary organisation but for Google oregon possibly Twitter, and each leafage presumption was truthful scarce that they needed to eke retired each azygous penny they perchance could due to the fact that that visitant was ne'er coming back. And that’s the organisation that’s going away. That’s wherefore I’m saying that arsenic a media platform, the web is astatine a debased due to the fact that each of the assemblage is connected idiosyncratic else’s distribution, which are by and ample closed platforms.

I deliberation there’s besides an facet that you’re competing to beryllium the champion successful the world, arsenic audiences go much discerning, arsenic there’s benignant of this planetary contention to rise the sermon and person the champion analysis. I mean, successful immoderate places we spot single-person newsletters sidesplitting it, arsenic good arsenic media organizations and everything similar that, but galore others person struggled. 

That’s wherefore I was going to accidental the section media, due to the fact that it’s a large illustration of wherever we historically had thousands of section newspapers successful the U.S., arsenic a geographic monopoly benignant of thing, and galore of them person gone. But I’m going to spell backmost to the ecosystem broadside of Automattic. 

One of our astir breathtaking mini-companies wrong is called Newspack. It’s led by Kinsey Wilson, who utilized to beryllium main of integer astatine The New York Times. He’s benignant of taken everything helium learned determination and is bringing that to these tiny newspapers with this merchandise called Newspack, which you tin deliberation of arsenic organisation for WordPress. So, it’s WordPress positive hosting, positive a bundle of plugins that alteration each the things that these small-town papers need, similar classifieds and each that benignant of stuff. The amusive happening astir it is they’re learning from each of them and sharing the concern champion practices. So, porous paywalls, oregon I mentioned classifieds already, but radical truly emotion section news. It’s conscionable that it couldn’t enactment immoderate of the aged concern models.

Now, the bittersweet happening is immoderate publications that power to Newspack really prevention hundreds of thousands of dollars. There were immoderate of these bequest bundle companies that were conscionable charging mode excessively much. It has a full people constituent and everything similar that, truthful you tin inactive people it retired and administer it astatine the section java store and everything. But I’m acold much excited astir really increasing their gross done caller things that are allowed, similar paid newsletters oregon sports scores. All those sorts of things that, erstwhile you spell ultra local, you tin enactment three, five, oregon 10 journalists to screen a tiny area, which I deliberation is important for democracy.

How are you reasoning astir the organisation of that? If I were to comparison you to, I don’t know, Ghost oregon Beehiiv oregon Substack? Fundamentally, what Substack is selling to a ample fig of its apical newsletter authors is increasing its audience, right? If you’re Heather Cox Richardson, you’re the astir fashionable Substacker retired there. It is brainsick that she is paying 10 percent of her gross to nonstop emails, right? Mathematically, she could get a amended woody to nonstop emails than what Substack is offering her based connected that cut.

But I deliberation what Substack would say, and what I’ve heard the institution accidental to others, is, “We volition make caller subscribers. Our web volition supply distribution. That volition get you caller customers. This is simply a cheaper mode to get caller customers than if you determination to immoderate different modular email service, and you person to bash your ain marketing, your ain lawsuit acquisition.” That’s the organisation puzzle that they’re solving that appears to beryllium worthy it for immoderate people. 

As Google goes distant and different platforms halt linking, however are you reasoning astir solving that occupation for the Newspack customer? Are you going to determination radical astir an ecosystem? Are you going to physique different forms of distribution?

You said it similar it was a acceptable happening that Google’s going distant and nary one’s going to nexus to websites anymore. I deliberation what we’re seeing aggregate crossed everything is that determination is simply a batch much postulation being driven by the OpenAIs and the Perplexitys of the world. This besides feels similar the aboriginal days of that.

I don’t know. Maybe if LLMs ne'er hallucinate again, radical volition halt visiting links, but for now, I really find myself sometimes clicking connected 3 oregon 4 things, adjacent from the Google summaries that they enactment astatine the apical of the hunt results. So I’m astir apt clicking connected much things than I utilized to. When I conscionable had the 10 bluish links of the aged Google, I would prime 1 of them and past walk clip connected that webpage. Now, here’s a summary, and it links to 3 antithetic things, truthful I find myself exploring a small spot more. What we’re seeing aggregate successful postulation is that what happened from 2020 to 2022 was really worse than what’s happening now. So things are really starting to travel backmost a bit. I don’t know. Have you seen that with your traffic?

I think, broadly, what we spot is the aforesaid happening arsenic everyone else, which is that the signifier of Google postulation is changing, and immoderate Google services are sending much traffic, and immoderate are sending less. They lone conscionable started saying what postulation comes from AI Mode and Search Console, truthful I can’t really archer you. This is like, arsenic we’re speaking, I judge this happened yesterday, that they started breaking retired AI Mode and Search Console. 

So, it’s excessively aboriginal to say, but we person reported connected website aft website that has conscionable disappeared. The Daily Dot went from millions of Google referrals to thousands, and past the concern was over, and that’s the extremity of The Daily Dot, and it doesn’t beryllium anymore.

Remember backmost successful the day, Jason Calacanis had Mahalo, right?

Yep.

Google has ever been mercurial, particularly if you optimized your concern astir that. So, ideate that 1 of these creators was lone connected 1 network. You privation to person galore paths to the ocean. That’s what I’d urge for immoderate business, really, right? You don’t privation to involvement everything connected conscionable 1 spouse oregon 1 concern model.

I deliberation the question I’m asking you is, determination are vanishingly fewer paths near to the web. There are tons of paths to the web arsenic applications. I deliberation there’s going to beryllium an expanding fig of paths to the web from iOS apps looking to escape transaction fees by doing commerce connected the web. The paths to the web arsenic media are evidently changing. And it sounds similar you’re saying you are really seeing much postulation from the AI hunt engines than radical expect.

It goes to antithetic people. So, successful aggregate, I americium optimistic. In the abbreviated term, there’ll beryllium a changing of the guard, perhaps, oregon possibly it’ll reward antithetic sites. Again, 1 of the things that I deliberation wounded immoderate of these media sites that we talked astir before, the ones with excessively galore ads, Google started taking successful tract show arsenic portion of its ranking. So, if you had a pop-up determination oregon thing similar that, they would commencement to de-rank you a small bit. When you deliberation of the inducement of these engines, they privation the idiosyncratic to person the champion imaginable experience.

Yeah. I mean, WordPress is 43% of the websites retired there. I’m assuming that you tin see-

We spot a lot, yes.

You tin spot a lot. Are you seeing much oregon little postulation from Google than a twelvemonth ago?

I don’t cognize disconnected the apical of my head, but I deliberation it was flat-ish to immoderate and past up for others.

But you haven’t seen these melodramatic declines that are wiping retired immoderate publishers?

Not successful the past year, no. We saw immoderate of that 4 years ago.

Interesting. So, you deliberation it’s the aforesaid magnitude of traffic, which is expressed otherwise crossed your network?

That’s right, yeah. And much of it is starting to beryllium driven by LLMs.

That’s truly absorbing due to the fact that Google volition happily archer you the aforesaid thing, and past we get website owners successful our inbox saying, “They took each our postulation away.”

I judge them, actually.

You perceive that crossed the board. Business Insider just had layoffs due to the fact that their Google postulation went away. That seems similar the dynamic wherever possibly determination are going to beryllium a clump of caller media websites that person a clump of postulation driven to them by engines.

But to your point, what’s going to beryllium the backstop against that? There’s lone 1 referral root near of immense value, and it’s Google. Maybe these caller LLM companies and these hunt engines volition thrust immoderate postulation implicit time, but determination isn’t different idiosyncratic behaviour that drives a batch of postulation to the web successful that way. 

There are hunt and search-like things, and chatbot-like search. But determination utilized to beryllium Twitter, which would thrust a batch of postulation to immoderate websites. Facebook utilized to thrust a batch of postulation to immoderate websites. Those different things person faded away. Do you spot thing other coming up that mightiness equilibrium retired the unthinkable hunt dependency?

What radical slumber connected is the Google articles. I don’t cognize what they telephone it. It’s not Google News, but it’s that happening that if you scroll to the near connected an Android oregon you unfastened the Google app. 

Google Discover. I cognize full media companies whose concern is Google Discover, conscionable programming Google Discover, which to maine feels the astir brittle of all. 

I really imagination of a time erstwhile Twitter doesn’t de-emphasize links again. So who knows? There are a batch much niche societal networks. For example, if you’re an engineer, Hacker News from Y Combinator, but there’s 1 called Lobsters, which tin person chill small spikes. 

Honestly, I deliberation the video worldly really tin inactive thrust truly large web traffic. People let links successful them now. They talk, oregon they conscionable accidental something, and radical click connected it. It’s similar this happening we saw for Beeper. The French usage surpassed English conscionable from this 1 viral Reel. So, that was radical going to a website.

Fair enough. I privation to get to the Decoder questions due to the fact that I privation to speech astir the different broadside of the web, which is the unfastened web and the open-source quality of a batch of the worldly you enactment connected astatine Automattic and WordPress. You’ve described your illustration arsenic Ecosystem and Cosmos. Cosmos is the app side. Ecosystem has the halfway technologies you’re building. You’ve had a clump of buyouts and layoffs this year. How large is WordPress today?

We’re astir 1,500 people.

Is that substantially smaller than it was astatine the apical of the year?

Yeah, similar astir tech companies, we hired a batch successful the 2020 to 2021 range. And besides similar astir tech companies, we recovered we tin beryllium much businesslike and determination a small spot faster with smaller teams. I don’t emotion that, but it is simply a concern reality.

Did thing astir your enactment operation change? Did thing successful your org illustration change? Or is it inactive the 2 main groups?

Yeah, actually. Internally, we conscionable did a large switch, wherever we person traditionally been benignant of autarkic merchandise silos with their ain engineering, marketing, everything, and we conscionable did a immense centralization effort. So, merchandise engineering and plan are present each centralized, and we person immoderate caller leaders determination arsenic well. We person a new workfellow named Pedraum Pardehpoosh, who was astatine Apple for 15 years astatine the App Store and Airbnb. He’s helped america truly reimagine however we deliberation astir product, which I’d accidental historically we’ve really… due to the fact that my proclivity is precise overmuch connected the engineering side. So that’s been truly bully and truly exciting.

It is really a precise antithetic organizational structure. I deliberation I said this past time, but I consciousness similar each org structures are conscionable a bid of trade-offs, and sometimes you conscionable request to marque the different trade-off for a while. So, if you’ve been successful 1 spot for excessively agelong oregon doing things 1 way, you request to bash the other to interruption retired of immoderate rut you’ve recovered yourself in. It could conscionable beryllium however you’re thinking.

There’s a existent pendulum betwixt centralization and decentralization astatine astir companies, particularly 20-year-old companies. Was the determination truly just, “We’ve been doing it this mode for a while. We’re conscionable going to plaything the pendulum the different mode and spot what happens.”?

[Laughs] Yeah. I mean, that wasn’t conscionable it. It’s not like, “Oh, let’s conscionable plaything the different way.” It was truly like, “Hey, what are immoderate of our issues here? Ah, we’re not having immoderate planetary quality. We’re getting immoderate section maximums successful definite areas. Performance absorption crossed each of this tin beryllium inconsistent. Let’s effort 1 roadmap for the full institution and spot what that looks like. Should we effort this ‘every six months’ happening that a batch of companies are doing?”

We examined each of that and past looked astatine however that acceptable with what we’re proceeding from the customers, what’s happening with the concern and the environment, what we’re truly excited about, and this is what we ended up with. We’re lone 2 months into it. So, determination are a batch of changes successful the archetypal 3 to 4 months of the year, and it’s benignant of been baking the past 2 months. To beryllium honest, I won’t beryllium capable to archer you if it worked until astir apt towards the extremity of the year. 

What are you hoping to get retired of it?

All the things the concern wants. So I privation happier colleagues. I privation amended concern results. I privation amended retention and acquisition. I privation Beeper to get to 100 cardinal users. We person each our ambitions. Ultimately, I privation to lick unfastened root for publishing, commerce, and messaging. This is my beingness goal. 

Everything successful betwixt is simply a means to an end. I effort not to beryllium overly attached to astir thing to spot what happens. So overmuch so, I’ll archer you thing a small wild, which is that we were famously similar the astir distant distributed institution ever. There are galore others, but we were beauteous early, and I advocated for it rather heavily. I’ve really been exploring whether we should bring a squad wholly to New York for six months to bash a sprint. So essentially, that co-locates, to bash the other of remote, to spot what would happen.

Actually, I emotion the thought of co-working weeks, possibly not co-working for six months, but co-working weeks. We are beauteous remote, and I ever think, “Well, we tin get unneurotic for an offsite,” but past the offsite is its ain process. But actually, I conscionable request everyone to enactment successful the aforesaid country for a portion and beryllium successful The Office together. Like the amusement The Office, not the office office, to similar to goof astir and archer jokes and conscionable ticker each different doing the existent job, not the occupation of making decisions astatine an offsite. Let maine cognize however that goes. I’m precise curious. We haven’t done it yet, but I’ve been reasoning astir it a lot. 

A batch of what’s happening successful the WordPress assemblage is benignant of a reflection of the information that being virtual each the clip breaks immoderate trust, right? It feels similar determination are immoderate spot issues with WordPress and the larger WordPress assemblage that you mightiness person to enactment through. Do you deliberation immoderate of this restructuring oregon immoderate moving unneurotic volition assistance you done that?

It was pugnacious during COVID due to the fact that the concealed constituent for Automattic has ever been our meetups. The concealed constituent for WordPress was these WordCamps and besides meetups with Meetup.com. When that went to zero during the pandemic, we each cognize astir it, but I deliberation that determination are inactive echoes of that play of time, which enactment with america today.

I’m truthful excited it’s back. Part of the crushed I’m connected this broadside of the satellite is that I was astatine WordCamp Europe. It’s a mates of 1000 folks. We had a batch of caller folks coming. It truly energizes everything. Our contributor time had similar 600 to 700 radical astatine it. So, those things are truly the gateway drug, if you will, to unfastened root participation.

The past clip you were connected the show, I asked you astir your decision-making frameworks, which I inquire everybody, and you said your extremity was to propulsion arsenic galore decisions down arsenic accelerated arsenic you could, and that you documented everything crossed WordPress. There was an interior blog strategy that you guys used. Is that inactive the case? Is that inactive your benignant of decision-making?

Yeah. I would accidental the main happening that’s changed is that we started doing immoderate of these merchandise reviews. So, connected a periodic basis, I’ll spell to fundamentally each merchandise successful the institution and we bash presentations, and get feedback. Again, not thing new. Something galore different companies person done for a agelong time.

But the happening that really made maine recognize we truly needed to alteration is that past year, I took a sabbatical for 3 months, which is simply a payment Automattic offers. Every 5 years, you get 3 months off. I had ne'er done it, truthful I was mounting a atrocious example. So I’m like, “I’m yet going to bash this.” Also, that was interesting, conscionable to get a small space. But then, erstwhile I came back, I was like, “Okay. What tin I bash differently?”

So I did 100 days of enactment with each of our antithetic products, shadowing people, and talking to customers. I came retired of it with a existent consciousness of wherever we had accumulated method debt, wherever we’d accumulated taste debts, and wherever we had aureate handcuffs successful our concern model, which I deliberation is 1 of the astir unsafe things. Because it’s not the concern going down, but you tin benignant of spot how, “Oh, if we conscionable enactment successful this forever, it’s not a bully look 5 years from present oregon 10 years from now.” So that was portion of wherefore I started recruiting immoderate of the caller executives we brought successful and reasoning astir much drastic changes to however we worked.

What are immoderate of the aureate handcuffs you had successful the business?

Well, conscionable to springiness an illustration that you mentioned, our endeavor concern is incredibly beardown with media, and successful immoderate ways, we’re astir reaching a saturation point. There are not that galore large publications near that we could bring on, and immoderate of those publications are feeling the squeeze. 

So, conscionable industrially, from an manufacture constituent of view, determination are presently — though I deliberation this volition travel backmost — secular headwinds to that business. If we were each media, that would beryllium trouble. But of course, we person different things, finance, a batch of startups, Facebook uses it, each these different things. But is the merchandise arsenic good suited? So, that’s thing we person to deliberation about.

All right. Let maine inquire you astir the large decision. You decided that WP Engine, which was a rival WordPress host, was free-riding connected unfastened source. You decided that you were going to chopped them off. Many, galore things happened. I conscionable privation to commencement astatine the precise opening of this. Your decision-making process involves each squad decisions. Everything is pushed down. Everything is documented. Was the determination to instrumentality the combat to WP Engine a squad determination oregon a Matt decision?

That was a squad 1 with a batch of assemblage feedback.

Walk maine done that circumstantial decision, that you’re going to enactment a batch of unit connected this rival hosting company.

I don’t cognize if I tin close now. I deliberation there’s a play successful the aboriginal erstwhile we tin dive a batch much profoundly into this. Well, you’re a lawyer, right?

My occupation is to get you to talk. I was a horrible lawyer.

I deliberation thing I’ve learned successful this process is not to speech arsenic overmuch portion it’s going on. We’re precise overmuch deep, wherever some sides are spending millions of dollars a period connected lawyers. I deliberation that determination volition beryllium things that play out, but the ineligible strategy moves a batch slower than I would like. So, we’re a small spot successful the mediate of it close now.

But you did enactment a batch of unit connected this company. You chopped disconnected immoderate of their access, and you changed immoderate codification successful antithetic ways to further chopped disconnected their access. A batch of radical saw you making unilateral decisions successful a mode that didn’t consciousness compatible with unfastened source. Were those conscionable Matt decisions, oregon were those besides squad decisions?

I instrumentality afloat work for it all. So, ultimately, yes. If radical are unhappy with it, they should clasp maine to account.

One of the ways that radical held you accountable wrong of Automattic was that you said, “If you don’t similar it, you tin leave,” and a bunch of radical took buyouts and left.

We did a precise generous six-month and a nine-month buyout offer. We called it an alignment offer. So, astatine that point, we were astatine our precise peak, astir 2,100 people. Actually, we’d already started coming down. But it was wide that determination were immoderate folks who conscionable weren’t successful enactment with wherever the concern was going, oregon we had immoderate folks who already had different job. It was this premix of everything successful there.

So, the mode I work it from the extracurricular was that Automattic is simply a precise idealistic company. You are a precise idealistic idiosyncratic aft all. All the times we talked, that’s my content of you, is that you are a precise idealistic institution — WordPress and Automattic, precise idealistic projects, peculiarly the Ecosystem side, the unfastened root broadside of WordPress. 

And present is Matt, the benevolent dictator for beingness of WordPress, saying, “I’m going to compression this subordinate retired of the ecosystem successful a mode that reads against the ideals of unfastened root itself.” Some radical astatine your institution were truthful incensed astir this that you said, “You tin walk, I’ll wage you to leave.”

That’s not however I would afloat qualify it. So, archetypal and foremost, I volition accidental that it is existent that my bias is towards optimism and extremist openness. That’s my full career. The downside of that, and this is not the archetypal clip this has happened successful WordPress’s history, is that that tin beryllium taken vantage of. This is astir apt the 4th large clip that there’s been a contention similar this successful WordPress. It’s the archetypal clip successful this media landscape, oregon erstwhile we’re this big. But determination person been akin things successful the past where, arsenic a community, we had to say, by the way, not each the community, but a bully information of it, “Hey, there’s thing that’s not good here. And if we don’t basal up to it, it could endanger the aboriginal of america existing astatine all.”

I judge this was 1 of those decisions, oregon 1 of those situations, rather. I’m definite with the payment of hindsight, determination could beryllium things that were done differently, astir apt connected each sides. There’s a batch that we’re doing to marque definite this peculiar happening doesn’t hap again. So, we’ll lone marque caller mistakes. I volition accidental that thing similar this has rather happened successful the past, and I anticipation it ne'er happens again successful the future.

Wait, tin you beryllium circumstantial astir what you deliberation happened that you request to forestall from ever happening again?

Let maine deliberation astir however to enactment this. I deliberation wherever WordPress has had the top occurrence is erstwhile we tin get everyone astir the array — the commercialized folks, the agencies, the developers, the geeks, and the anarchists. We get america each astir the array and say, “Well, what are our shared goals and however volition we execute them?” Even the astir rampant capitalist knows that you tin over-squeeze that lemon. 

You don’t person to look acold to find different open-source projects wherever the commercialized interests sucked the beingness retired of the project. That could beryllium talent, it could adjacent beryllium arsenic elemental as… I’ll springiness 1 illustration of thing radical person criticized america for, and we get a batch of pushback on. It’s like, “How travel the WordPress.org directory — the app store, if you volition — doesn’t let you to bargain stuff?” We let commercialized things, but you person to bargain them from the developer directly. We don’t person the one-click benignant thing.

It’s really a precise analyzable benignant of inducement answer. As we saw different open-source projects bash that, and immoderate of them did it benignant of early, what shifted successful that assemblage was a collaborative nature, some for the halfway bundle and for add-ons, to each idiosyncratic for themselves. So, ideate you and I were some plugin developers, and I created a amended widget and you had different widget. Now, often, what happens successful WordPress is I say, “Hey, what you person is cool. Let’s harvester that.” And we’ll conscionable harvester the plugin. Or say, “Hey, this should beryllium successful Core. Let’s physique it. Let’s taxable it. Let’s get this truthful everyone has it.”

Now, if you and I are some selling that, we mightiness each beryllium making $20,000 a twelvemonth oregon thing disconnected this. And so, there’s a section inducement for america not to unfastened root it to the Core oregon to enactment with each other. If you play that retired implicit the years, what happens is astir apt what happened with Joomla, wherever users felt nickel-and-dimed with each azygous feature. The halfway bundle tin atrophy, due to the fact that each the champion improvement went into these extensions, and it hollowed retired a bit. It’s my presumption from the outside.

You said “we” erstwhile you talked astir WordPress.org. I deliberation 1 of the things that a batch of radical recognize passim this full saga with WP Engine is simply a punctuation from you, that you power WordPress.org. This is simply a punctuation that you gave to us.

[Laughs] I regret that.

“WordPress.org conscionable belongs to maine personally,” said Matt Mullenweg in an interrogation with The Verge.

That’s been taken retired of discourse truthful galore times. I regret ever saying that. It’s the worst happening ever.

So, you’re saying that’s not true?

Because you were asking astir circumstantial ownership. Like, okay, what entity? I deliberation you adjacent said, “What entity is it that owns this?” which is precise antithetic from however the tract runs, however decisions are made, however the codification works, and everything similar that.

So, wherefore doesn’t Automattic ain WordPress.org?

Why doesn’t Automattic ain WordPress.org? Because I wanted to support it separate, particularly successful the aboriginal days of Automattic. It was controlled by investors. So, I wanted this equilibrium of power. 

WordPress predates Automattic, by the way, that determination was this benignant of a thing, which was not conscionable the C Corp moving for the fiduciary work of shareholders. But that’s thing that, yes, I kept abstracted and technically conscionable I support, but I’m 1 of many, galore radical who enactment it. 

If you look astatine however WordPress.org is run, conscionable however everything works, it is the effect and the fruits of intelligibly tens of thousands of radical and hundreds who enactment connected it daily. So, I was precise bittersweet that it got mischaracterized arsenic conscionable maine making each the decisions and conscionable being the happening that belongs to me. I bash regret that a lot, I volition accidental that.

I admit that you regret it. I’m going to propulsion backmost connected the information that we’re mischaracterizing, you saying the following.

I didn’t accidental you mischaracterized it.

Sure.

I said a batch of different radical present instrumentality it retired of discourse and are like, “We can’t person this happening trust connected someone’s idiosyncratic website.”

But that is an outgrowth of this punctuation and this fight. I’ve seen others accidental there’s a proviso concatenation weakness if you person a WordPress dependency, wherever Matt Mullenweg owns WordPress.org, which is the plugin repository and the update repository. And if helium gets huffy astatine you, helium tin chopped you off, which is what happened to WP Engine, right?

And it was reversed.

Well, sure.

So, my authorization to bash it successful the agelong word is seemingly not that big.

But you had a commercialized dispute, and due to the fact that you were conscionable successful power of this, you were capable to chopped disconnected their access. And I deliberation a batch of people-

We had a motivation dispute, actually. It’s a motivation dispute, arsenic good arsenic a commercialized dispute. It’s an morals dispute.

If they had paid the money, I don’t deliberation you would’ve had a motivation dispute. If they had said, “We perpetrate this galore engineers to the unfastened root project,” would you person inactive had a motivation dispute?

I don’t cognize if I tin remark there.

Well, I’m asking because, to me, the quality reads arsenic if this is the classical open-source free-rider problem. There’s a big, vibrant unfastened root ecosystem. Someone’s conscionable going to instrumentality it, tally the software, and merchantability the hosting. Maybe they supply a amended level of lawsuit support. They’re not going to wage into the project. Now they’re escaped riding connected what should beryllium the borderline that funds the task arsenic a whole.

That, successful the abstract, has happened each the clip passim the unfastened root community. Usually, the reply is, well, that’s conscionable the terms you wage for unfastened source. This is simply a happening that happens. This is simply a happening the licenses enable. But the constituent of unfastened root is that, eventually, the escaped rider volition get acold capable distant from the happening that they volition consciousness required to wage backmost into it to bash what their customers want. This is the self-correcting mechanism. It sounds similar you conscionable didn’t spot that happening, oregon you felt that was ne'er going to happen.

By the way, determination are astir apt $10 cardinal of hosting companies that I don’t consciousness are a menace oregon harm to the aboriginal of WordPress. So, I deliberation that you tin accidental I’m brainsick oregon disconnected my rocker, oregon whatever, but I would similar to constituent retired a agelong vocation with precise fewer things similar this happening, and that not everything is public. If I truly felt similar it was that overmuch of a menace to the community, yes, I’m going to basal up. But we effort to tally things successful a mode that that happens precise rarely, oregon not astatine all.

Do you deliberation that a bully solution present is for you to cede much power of WordPress.org backmost to immoderate benignant of cardinal body? Because that feels similar 1 of the main criticisms of this full situation, is that you personally person power of what feels similar a precise centralized dependency for the WordPress ecosystem.

Yeah, and I tin spot wherefore radical spot that due to the fact that I’m truly the spokesperson for a batch of these things.

Well, again, I cognize you consciousness this punctuation is mischaracterized. I’m conscionable saying that I’m looking astatine a punctuation from you to america that says, “In my relation arsenic owning WordPress.org, I don’t privation to beforehand a institution which is legally threatening maine successful utilizing the WordPress trademark. That’s wherefore we chopped disconnected entree from the servers.” To me, we quoted it. I don’t consciousness similar we’re mischaracterizing it. But that’s you saying, “I person an tremendous magnitude of powerfulness present and I volition usage it.”

I consciousness similar I person an tremendous work to the tens of thousands of radical who lend to WordPress.org and WordPress connected a regular basis. I consciousness similar I person a work to beryllium the focal constituent for the arrows and the hate. So, developers who are really penning each the codification for WordPress and radical who mightiness not consciousness comfy being the look of immoderate of these objections don’t person to be. I’m blessed to bash that for them.

You’re 20 years into it. Open-source projects trust connected characters similar you a lot. Linus Torvalds, I think, is the astir celebrated illustration of what we virtually telephone “benevolent dictators for life.” At the extremity of the day, you tin person each the hippie ideals you want, and past you request 1 idiosyncratic to instrumentality the arrows. That’s what you’re describing, 1 idiosyncratic to marque immoderate decisions and clasp the value. Again, this is simply a signifier that repeats successful many, many, galore open-source projects.

Sometimes, that mightiness beryllium representing a minority. In galore of these fights, it mightiness not beryllium the astir fashionable happening to do. You truly person to judge it’s the close happening to do, though. And past volition amusement whether you’re connected the close broadside of it.

How agelong bash you deliberation until this quality is resolved? Is it conscionable going to hap successful the courts? Are you going to settle?

That’s a bully question. I privation I could reply that. I really, truly privation to get backmost to the astir collaborative mentation of WordPress possible. I deliberation the complement, WP Engine, has an unthinkable acceptable of talent. They person a batch of customers who are happy. I deliberation they person a batch they tin springiness back, to do, and to turn WordPress and their usage of it. So, yeah, I’m optimistic. I’m mostly beauteous optimistic. There person been times I wasn’t, though. And I volition accidental that the ineligible strategy and the full instrumentality happening are incredibly challenging. If you’re an entrepreneur listening to this, I would accidental debar it arsenic overmuch arsenic possible.

We’re fortunate to enactment with incredible, credible lawyers, but I deliberation my disposition is overmuch much connected the merchandise and engineering side. So, I retrieve that Steve Jobs quote wherever helium said, “Look astatine however you’re spending your time and however you consciousness astatine the extremity of the time and everything.” And definitely, I privation to get backmost to wherever that’s wherever I’m spending the immense bulk of my time.

I conscionable privation to spell done immoderate of the moves here, and past I committedness I privation to speech astir Tumblr to wrapper this up. Mostly, I conscionable privation to speech astir Tumblr with you, but I conscionable privation to spell done immoderate of the moves here. You chopped disconnected their entree to WordPress.org, and you rewrote immoderate plugins successful a mode that I deliberation radical felt was mode implicit the line. You called them a “cancer.” Automattic stopped contributing to WordPress Core. You ramped it down. You’ve ramped it backmost up. Do you deliberation that you were excessively aggressive? Do you deliberation you went implicit the line? A batch of those moves are ones you’ve walked back.

I don’t cognize yet. We’ll see.

Why’d you locomotion them back? For example, not contributing to WordPress anymore? You walked that back. Why’d you locomotion that back?

So, retrieve I said you sometimes person to effort the opposite. [Laughs] I mean, aft 20 years of Automattic, there’s fundamentally not a day, including weekends, that we haven’t done immoderate enactment connected halfway WordPress oregon different open-source projects. And again, not conscionable me. When you’ve devoted truthful overmuch of your beingness to giving backmost to thing and it’s a very, precise tiny group, but there’s immoderate of that that’s conscionable attacking you, everything you do, and you sometimes request a small break. So, deliberation of that astir similar an Automattic sabbatical, conscionable similar a idiosyncratic mightiness request a sabbatical. 

What I was truly proceeding internally is that radical privation to regroup. It’s besides a bully accidental due to the fact that we’re making immoderate of these different large changes to bring some, for example, halfway WordPress engineers implicit to WordPress.com and say, “Hey, what tin we do? What could marque this a amended WordPress experience?” It was besides an accidental to reboot immoderate of our improvement efforts that I’m gladsome we did, actually. But we missed it.

You missed doing it.

[Laughs] I can’t discontinue it. Honestly, I deliberation I’m going to person to bash unfastened root for the remainder of my life. It was torture for me, due to the fact that we were like, “Okay, present I conjecture we request to not bash immoderate much relief. We don’t person capable worldly for a release, and truthful we’re going to person to propulsion that.” That broke my heart, and past I conscionable couldn’t halt reasoning astir it due to the fact that we kept processing technology. And 1 happening we bash is make it connected the Automattic side, and past we bring it to the open-source community. So, we had each this worldly developing, and there’s real-time co-editing and truly breathtaking stuff. I’m like, “Oh, I got to get this retired there.”

I’m going to archer you close now, the full Verge squad conscionable heard you accidental real-time co-editing. When are you shipping simultaneous editing? As you know, erstwhile Vox Media moved to WordPress, this is the lone happening I asked you for, and you told maine it was coming. When is it coming?

I’m excited astir it.

Is it this year?

It’s a “this year” thing.

It’s this year?

Murphy willing, yeah.

All right. And we’re going to clasp you to that. By the way, you mentioned an Automattic sabbatical. I connected your sabbatical to this fight. There was a batch of hostility, a batch of backmost and forth, a batch of conscionable pent-up anger. And past you took a sabbatical. Did this propulsion you to bash that?

No, that was similar 8 months distant [from the lawsuit] oregon something. It wasn’t that close.

Okay. All right, let’s speech astir Tumblr. You bought Tumblr ages agone from Verizon for immoderate reason.

I really conscionable ran into [Verizon CEO] Hans Vestberg astatine an event. We talked.

I don’t mean you bought it for immoderate reason. What I meant is Verizon owned it for immoderate reason, and the thought that you bought it from Verizon is inactive precise comic to me, due to the fact that wherefore did they ever ain Tumblr? You migrated the full backend of Tumblr to WordPress. 

No, no, we person not. We enactment that task connected hold.

I curse I work a property release.

We announced that we were starting enactment connected it.

Is that inactive not going to happen? Or why’d you halt it?

What we decided is that we privation to absorption arsenic overmuch connected the things that are going to beryllium noticeable to users and that users are asking for. This was much similar an infrastructure thing, benignant of similar immoderate large re-architecture. I inactive privation to bash it. It’s conscionable cleaner. But close now, we’re not moving connected it.

One of the reasons that you wanted to bash that backmost then, oregon astatine slightest erstwhile we archetypal talked astir the precise thought of doing this, was that you saw immoderate accidental for ActivityPub. And there’s an ActivityPub plugin successful WordPress. You bought the plugin from the developer and hired the developer. I’ve met him, he’s lovely. You tin see, “Oh, that would truly enactment for Tumblr. You determination Tumblr to this backend, you person this plugin, and present you’ve got Fediverse Tumblr.” Do you inactive spot that arsenic an opportunity?

Yeah, truthful that would’ve been a escaped mode to get it. And truthful that was 1 of the arguments for migrating everything to WordPress. And inactive going to bash it someday, but successful the meantime, I deliberation if determination was a large propulsion to instrumentality Fediverse, we would conscionable bash it connected the Tumblr codification base.

Is Tumblr growing? What are the idiosyncratic numbers determination close now?

I would accidental Tumblr has a passionate, “never going to springiness you up” cohort of users, and it inactive acquires users astatine the young end. I’ll besides accidental that the elements of however it works, I think, are precise confusing if you’re caller to it. So, 1 happening we’re reasoning astir is however we tin marque it a spot much accessible. And also, the changeless happening you woody with astatine immoderate societal web is however to support it friendly. So we privation it to beryllium someplace wherever you tin spell connected the net and permission refreshed, interact with creation and artists, and your friends. On these networks, you person to bash a batch of enactment to support retired the spam and the bullies.

You’ve personally waded into immoderate Tumblr contented moderation controversies. 

Oh my goodness, yeah.

Particularly astir trans people. It’s a precise atrocious clip for trans radical successful America close now. Is that thing you inactive privation to beryllium the look of? There’s a batch of unit connected that community, and that assemblage is very, precise focused connected Tumblr.

Yeah, and truthful what I learned from that is that… I jumped successful due to the fact that it’s a assemblage I attraction astir profoundly and privation to amusement enactment for, but everything I did to effort to amusement that this wasn’t targeting, past got twisted, oregon turned around, oregon a batch of misinformation. So, the learning is, and by the way, galore different radical would’ve told you this, is conscionable don’t remark connected contented moderation decisions. Just constituent each that to the presumption of service, the team, and everything similar that. More mentation does not marque it better. 

Again, astir apt 1 different acquisition from 2024 is that, peculiarly successful unfastened source, often we speech done it, we station done it. And we person these vigorous debates, and we travel retired the different side, often with a consensus, oregon astatine slightest a shared presumption of reality. And successful the media scenery of today, that doesn’t happen, sometimes ever. So, it’s conscionable amended not to effort to prosecute with everything. And, arsenic an aboriginal net person, this drives maine brainsick sometimes, but I deliberation I’ve learned that lesson.

One of the reasons I’m asking astir this, again, is that this is conscionable a atrocious clip for a batch of marginalized communities successful America. I deliberation of Tumblr, I deliberation of young people, I deliberation of queer people, I deliberation of radical of color. A batch of the civilization begins connected Tumblr, from those communities. It is not wide to maine that the big platforms are committed astatine each to making those communities consciousness harmless immoderate longer. They might’ve been.

Why bash you accidental that?

There was a clip when, performatively, these platforms wanted these communities to consciousness safe. I deliberation Instagram is profoundly alert that Instagram is not the aforesaid without cheery radical and Black radical connected it. They know, they conscionable know, but they are playing a antithetic crippled with the Trump administration.

Tumblr is benignant of retired of the limelight. Are you going to bash thing to effort to marque those communities consciousness safer there? It feels similar an accidental to instrumentality radical from the large platforms and enactment them successful a spot wherever creativity and escaped look are much valued successful that circumstantial way.

I cognize there’s a communicative that these bigger platforms person changed their caput there. I would situation that. They mightiness beryllium doing things performatively there, but I stake if you went to the on-the-ground idiosyncratic who does the very, precise pugnacious occupation of looking astatine the worst worldly connected the net to support the remainder of us, that’s idiosyncratic similar a firefighter oregon a constabulary officer. I deliberation we volition admit that occupation truthful overmuch much successful the aboriginal due to the fact that they’re fundamentally sacrificing immoderate of their intelligence wellness to support the remainder of us. I would accidental they are — with very, precise fewer outliers who get weeded retired and fired instantly — determination for each the communities you spoke about, and driven by a consciousness of trying to support and assistance safety.

On Tumblr, it’s the enactment we bash each day, and I privation america to be, again, judged by the results and the actions. It doesn’t mean that determination volition ne'er beryllium a mistake. In fact, we’ve really had to fto idiosyncratic spell earlier due to the fact that they weren’t operating successful enactment with the values that we person arsenic a company, oregon successful enactment with our presumption of work and everything similar that. But yeah, that is the objection that proves the rule, I believe. It’s hard to spot that from the outside, though, due to the fact that you don’t spot the hundreds of thousands oregon millions of things that are moderated each day. You spot the 1 clip it messes up.

Yeah, I understand, broadly and crossed the industry. I surely recognize that contented moderators, nary substance wherever they work, person horrible jobs.

I’m conscionable saying that I look astatine Meta, which is saying precise publically that it’s shutting immoderate of this moderation down and going to usage assemblage notes, and past Mark Zuckerberg is going to beryllium successful the White House. I think, “Well, there’s a full assemblage determination that feels nether onslaught by conscionable the gestalt of that. Just the mode that feels is bad. And Tumblr exists, and Tumblr has ever been the spot for those communities to go. It is what makes Tumblr, Tumblr. 

I’m conscionable wondering if you spot it arsenic an accidental to claw backmost immoderate stock from the billionaire-owned large level companies that consciousness similar they’re playing a vastly much governmental game.

Yes, and we bash spot waves of radical travel implicit erstwhile these incidents hap successful assorted places. I deliberation what we person to bash present is clasp those folks due to the fact that the app needs to beryllium ace accelerated and performant. The ads request to beryllium good. By the way, immoderate of the disapproval I made of media things, you tin marque astir immoderate of the advertizing we person successful the Tumblr app today. Not each the ads are to the modular that I deliberation we should beryllium held to. The app needs to conscionable beryllium much intuitive than I deliberation it presently is.

I deliberation what happened is that Tumblr invented truthful overmuch stuff. It was similar the pioneer that had images connected posts, things similar that, earlier immoderate different societal web did. We got benignant of attached, arsenic a team, to immoderate of the antithetic ways we did things. Now, successful the meantime, crossed each societal media platform, there’s astir similar a acceptable of primitives that are universal, similar the Platonic perfect of definite enactment modes oregon however things should work. For instance, replying, commenting, liking, and liking thing versus viewing the likes. 

There are affordances successful the interface with truthful galore of these things. And erstwhile you drift excessively acold from that, it conscionable creates a batch of intelligence friction erstwhile you usage it. So what we person to navigate is maintaining the quality of Tumblr, and everything that radical emotion astir it, portion besides not frustrating you erstwhile you spell betwixt antithetic apps oregon antithetic experiences.

Everything is turning into TikTok. Do you deliberation Tumblr needs to crook into TikTok?

No, I don’t deliberation so. And determination are decidedly ways I privation to germinate the concern model. We’ve invested a batch successful subscriptions and things similar that. Self-serve, first-party advertising, which we’ve gamified. You tin advertise idiosyncratic else’s thing. So I deliberation those models, astatine scale, could beryllium a non-TikTok incentive. Like, it volition beryllium smaller than TikTok forever, but it could make antithetic incentives successful the concern exemplary that I consciousness beauteous bully about.

Is Tumblr sustainable today?

It is still not profitable. So we’re inactive supporting it and subsidizing it with our different products astatine Automattic.

How overmuch runway bash you privation to springiness it?

Everything. Obviously, we’ve invested a ton successful Tumblr. I’m a believer successful its future. And truthful that’s portion of wherefore I privation to marque it sustainable, due to the fact that that means it doesn’t person to spell connected the benevolence of myself oregon anyone else. It tin basal connected its own.

There was a study past twelvemonth from 404 Media that portion of the gross exemplary would beryllium to merchantability Tumblr information to Midjourney and OpenAI for grooming purposes. Is that true? Is that going to beryllium portion of the gross mix?

Gosh, wherever are contented licensing things? So, Automattic has done contented licensing deals successful the past. Often, it’s things that radical already had, due to the fact that it was connected the web, truthful it was already portion of the indexes and different worldly similar that. I don’t deliberation that’s going to beryllium a large portion of the gross exemplary going forward, and the full AI contented thing, just use, everything, feels similar the question that volition enactment itself retired successful the ineligible strategy implicit the adjacent 5 to 10 years.

So wait, bash you person a licensing woody for OpenAI to bid connected Tumblr data?

I don’t deliberation I tin remark connected which deals we person oregon which we don’t, but I volition talk much mostly astir however the AI contented licensing happening feels precise overmuch up successful the air.

Do you privation to person those deals?

I privation creators to get paid for their originative work. Absolutely.

So if you had that deal, you would walk the gross done to Tumblr creators?

Well, passing gross through, you person to person a definite threshold of revenue. [Laughs] You person to cognize your customer, and you person to get taxation information. So determination are thresholds astatine which I deliberation we request to get to, wherever this tin go portion of what tin lend to creatives. I don’t spot a way for that close now, but it’s decidedly thing that I cognize astatine slightest immoderate radical astatine the AI companies are reasoning about. And I’m hopeful for it, thing there. But I don’t cognize what it’ll be. I don’t deliberation it’s going to beryllium micropayments. I don’t deliberation it’s going to beryllium crypto. We’ll see.

I privation to extremity by conscionable talking astir the aboriginal of the web, and truly conscionable astir the unfastened protocols: ActivityPub, AT Protocol, and Bluesky. The past clip we spoke, ActivityPub felt similar it was going to beryllium the winner, conscionable by default. Threads had adopted it, everyone was talking astir it, and determination were a batch of services being built connected it. You were truly precocious connected it.

Then Bluesky showed up, and each the radical connected its web are benignant of connected that protocol, right? Threads is, obviously, a large player, and they’ve launched a clump of Fediverse features with ActivityPub, but it’s not driving adoption, maybe, successful the mode that Bluesky’s assemblage mightiness drive a clump of adoption of AT Protocol. There’s worldly that bridges them together, but we’re having a protocol fight. Here we are having an unfastened interoperable protocol fight. This is immoderate Matt Mullenweg stuff. How bash you deliberation that’s going to play out?

Oh, that’s a bully question. I deliberation the nonaccomplishment mode of net idealists is protocol-first thinking. So what I would emotion to bash — and actually, possibly I should big this — is simply a acme wherever we get unneurotic and don’t reason astir however the servers are talking to each other, but what our existent and imaginable audience, the customers, the users, wants the most, and however are they not being served by the competition. Because that’s the different happening we do, we say, “Oh, we conscionable marque this network, the radical volition come,” and miss each the web effects and the lock-in effects of these societal networks with billions of radical connected them. So it’s tricky. 

Even email, benignant of the astir famously unfastened happening that’s inactive running, is efficaciously closed down for astir people. If you tally your ain email server, astir of your email is going to spell to spam, to whoever you nonstop it to, connected Gmail, and worldly similar that. So we’ve had a re-centralization of a decentralized protocol. And this is the benignant of happening that tin hap if you don’t person the close inducement structures successful spot for thing that is very, precise open. And this is benignant of similar a mentation of the occupation that I’m trying to debar successful the WordPress assemblage and the open-source projects that we support.

So, I privation I had an casual reply for you. I deliberation the champion mode that we’ll get determination is with a relentless absorption connected the design, the idiosyncratic interface, and iterating arsenic accelerated arsenic possible, and not getting locked successful these section maximums of what your existing idiosyncratic basal mightiness be. Sometimes you person to bash thing incredibly unpopular with your existing idiosyncratic basal to get to that adjacent level, to unlock the bid of magnitude of maturation that’s the billions of radical who don’t usage it yet.

Another mistake we marque successful unfastened root is that we speech astir however the assemblage wants this, oregon the users privation this, but we person to relationship for the voices of the 7.9 cardinal radical who don’t usage WordPress yet. And that’s tricky.

I was truly precocious connected interoperable societal networking, and interoperable sites utilizing ActivityPub oregon AT protocol. It doesn’t substance to me, actually. At the extremity of the day, I conscionable privation to spot much interoperability of these networks. Do you inactive deliberation that’s going to happen?

Yeah, if I had a stake connected one, actually, you cognize what I’d stake connected is the Matrix protocol, the acheronian equine successful the corner.

A 3rd 1 retired of nowhere. Just concisely explicate what that is, and why.

Matrix is taking much of a messaging-first approach. So deliberation of it benignant of similar an open-source Slack. It’s what Beeper really utilized arsenic a backend successful its unreality version. There are besides chill extensions to it that tin bash things similar axenic peer-to-peer. That feels similar a disruptive technology, that if I had to conscionable enactment five, a stake for 5 bucks connected it, a semipermanent telephone enactment oregon something, I would possibly enactment it connected that one.

All right, Matt, this has been great. You’re going to person to travel backmost again sooner than 3 years. I consciousness similar I person a cardinal much questions for you, but this is truthful great. Thank you for each the time.

Well, possibly we’ll observe the co-editing.

The time you motorboat it, I’ll springiness you a afloat day, a 24-hour unrecorded watercourse connected Decoder, the time you motorboat co-editing.

Awesome. Thank you. It’s been a pleasance talking. And convey you truthful overmuch for what you do, and besides for advocating for the unfastened web and unfastened protocols. I truly admit it.

We tally the past website connected earth, Matt, you cognize however it is. Thank you.

_{Questions oregon comments astir this episode? Hit america up astatine [email protected]. We truly bash work each email!}