Apple Wins Partial Dismissal in First-Gen AirPods Pro Crackling Lawsuit

Apple was not capable to get an AirPods Pro people enactment suit filed successful November 2024 dismissed, but the justice overseeing the lawsuit did propulsion retired immoderate of the claims this week, giving the institution a partial win.


The suit covers the first-generation AirPods Pro, accusing Apple of mendacious advertizing for selling AirPods Pro models with ongoing crackling oregon static issues. Shortly aft the AirPods Pro went connected sale, customers began complaining of crackling, rattling, popping, and static-like noises. Apple issued a bundle update successful May 2020 to effort to hole the problem, and past aboriginal launched a repair program successful October 2020.

The customers who filed the suit requested alleviation owed to the defective quality of the AirPods Pro, and they said they would not person purchased the earbuds oregon would person paid little if Apple was forthcoming astir the flaw.

Apple filed a question to disregard the suit successful March 2025, starring to the mixed effect handed down this week. Claims related to immoderate authorities fraud and user instrumentality were dismissed, arsenic were those related to explicit warranty and implied warranty. Nationwide claims were besides thrown retired due to the fact that the plaintiffs failed to contiguous a typical plaintiff from each state, which the tribunal said is required for nationwide counts. Some plaintiff-specific claims were dropped, and a assertion for unjust enrichment successful California did not survive. The tribunal besides denied injunctive alleviation due to the fact that the archetypal AirPods Pro are nary longer offered for sale.

The fraud by omission claims survived, and Apple is accused of failing to disclose known AirPods Pro defects adjacent aft acknowledging them publically with the 2020 work program. Several of the state, nationwide, and warranty claims tin beryllium amended and refiled with much accusation successful the adjacent 21 days, truthful immoderate of the claims could beryllium revived arsenic the lawsuit goes on.

Plaintiffs volition request to beryllium that Apple was alert of the defect and concealed it pursuing the 2020 repair program, and that the institution denied valid warranty repairs for those claims to determination forward.

The surviving fraud by omission assertion could beryllium to beryllium an obstacle for the plaintiffs aboriginal successful the determination process, and it could yet beryllium dismissed. Citing anterior lawsuit law, Apple argued that it lone has to disclose information issues aft the warranty play has expired, and the AirPods Pro dependable defect was not a information hazard. The tribunal did not cull Apple's argument, and simply said that it was premature for it to see the contented astatine this stage.
This article, "Apple Wins Partial Dismissal successful First-Gen AirPods Pro Crackling Lawsuit" archetypal appeared connected MacRumors.com

Discuss this article successful our forums